Meet Meridian: a mid-sized Polish retail-and-services company — around 450 employees, 32 stores, and a growing e-commerce arm
In two years, annual staff turnover has risen from 14% to 27%, and customer satisfaction scores are falling
The board wants evidence, not hunches — and you are the junior research team advising it
Notice what the board has actually given you: not a research question but a problem — a gap between how things are and how it wants them to be
The work of this session is the journey from that problem to a question research can answer
Where do research topics come from?
The key process is turning an idea or general concern into a topic that can become a research problem
Don’t begin by asking “what shall I write about?” — ask “what do I want to understand or learn about?”
Sources of topics include:
Practical problems — a turnover spike, a falling satisfaction score, a failing product
Existing research — course readings, journals, and studies that leave questions open
Your own prior work — written work or projects you have already undertaken
Received wisdom — “common sense” claims circulating in the media or the organisation that nobody has tested systematically
In organisations, the richest source is the gap between what people believe and what has actually been checked
What makes a good research topic?
Before committing to a topic, ask five hard questions of it:
Will anyone care about the answer? — relevance to the organisation or to knowledge
Is the problem solvable in the time available? — a semester, not a career
Will I add something new? — or has the question already been answered well
Do I have good tools to address it? — methods, skills, and data within reach
What makes me think I will succeed? — an honest audit of your resources
These questions echo last week’s three criteria — relevance, feasibility, ethics — but sharpen them into a working checklist
Running example: “why are people leaving Meridian?” passes easily — the board cares, data and staff are accessible, and a semester is enough to make real progress.
Getting the scope right
Narrowing a topic: six strategies
Research practicalities
A topic must also survive contact with practical reality:
Can you physically access the object of your research?
Are there gatekeepers who can grant or deny access — and will they?
Will there be political or administrative obstacles?
Can you actually reach the people you need to survey, interview, or observe?
Do you have the language skills you need?
If using existing documents or data, can you actually get at the materials?
Ultimately, a good research topic is one you can investigate with the resources you have available
Running example: studying Meridian’s staff needs the board’s blessing — but studying its competitors’ staff would founder on access, however interesting the comparison.
Research goals
Three goals of research
Goals combine and sequence
From topic to research question
Why research questions matter
A topic tells you what territory you are in; a research question tells you what, exactly, you must find out
The research question does three jobs at once:
Guides the research — every later decision refers back to it
Determines the scope — it fixes what is inside and outside the study
Shapes the methodology — the wording of the question points toward the methods that can answer it
A study without a clear question drifts: data get collected because they are available, not because they are needed
The question is the heart of the study — everything else is anatomy around it
Matching question to goal: Meridian
Managerial question ≠ research question
Criteria and common flaws
What makes a sound research question?
Flaw: too broad, and unanswerable
Flaw: double-barrelled, and leading
Flaw: value-laden, and trivial
Flaw: not researchable, and prediction without mechanism
Conclusion
Conclusion
Research starts before data: the journey from a managerial problem to a researchable question is itself methodological work — and it is where most studies are won or lost
A good topic passes the tests of relevance, feasibility, and practicality — and sits at the right scope: not a field, not an incident
Every study serves a goal — exploration, description, or explanation — and the goal disciplines the question: what could be going on, what is happening, why is it happening
Sound questions are answerable, focused, feasible, and non-trivial; the common flaws — double-barrelled, leading, value-laden, unanswerable, too broad, trivial, unresearchable, mechanism-free prediction — are all failures of one of these
When we next meet, we take the step this session deliberately stopped short of: turning questions into hypotheses and variables, and choosing a research design
Questions and discussion are welcome
Exercise
Today’s exercise: twenty questions on today’s lecture, answered on your phone. Some ask you to read a short extract first.